Doug Wilson (dare I invoke him?) had an interesting observation on Christ’s passion in the garden. “Father, if you are willing, let this cup pass from me!” (Luke 22:42) Might not a possible reply have been: “Oh, you know, OK, we’ll let Mahomet deal with this later. Never mind. Go home.” Could not the cross simply have been a quirk of fate? Was not the cross really an unfortunate outcome of a cosmic game of chance with many ways out of the predicament? Of course not, scripture is clear, the ensuing silence from the Father confirms: No, there is no other way. Not Mahomet, not Buddha, not self-actualization in a postmodernist utopia.
And yet, Wilson does not take this logic to its ultimate conclusion. Seems to me the “No other way” of Gethsemane had a deeper and more profound significance than simply a sectarian exclusivity. Consider John 1:3 “Through him all things were made; without him nothing was made that has been made.” The passion says it all: “Father, could we not have made a universe where I need not do this?” and the silence answers: “No, this is the only way to have the universe We desire. This is the best of all possible worlds. You know this. You designed it this way before the beginning of time.”
The implications are significant. This world, warts and all, sin and all, is the best of all possible worlds. Sin is not a bug the programming, it is a design feature. Sin, though evil, deplorable, wicked and dark, to be shunned and rescued from by our glorious redeemer; is still necessary for the creation of the kind of world the Godhead desired, designed and destined. Sin serves a purpose; it serves the Father, though we are the author of it.
Is the world all chaos where the Father has to repeatedly step in and correct things only for us to mess it all up again in short order? Does He not know the hairs on our head (Luke 12:7), our needs before we ask (Matt 6:8), our failures before we fall (john 16:22)? Do we not do so with our own children? The crayon on the wall was expected, we saw it coming, we were prepared. We instructed, once, twice, seventy times seven? The child failed but learned to be creative in more creative ways. He learned because he first failed. He learned because we knew he would fail and let him, because we taught him through it and were patient. We knew his path and were confident. To do otherwise would result in enfeebled, incompetent screwups good for nothing (Lukianoff & Haidt, 2019). If we, limited as we are, are able to raise our children, how much more will God?
What matters is how we orient ourselves to the universe that is. Do we accept the world as God has made it and orient ourselves towards God or do we try to create an alternate universe where we can orient towards ourselves? Do we accept the Lord’s discipline as what needs be done so we become as we should be, or do we fight it fist and claw? Do we recognize that the world is the way it is as God glorifies Himself in it and in us? Or do we shut Him out to try and keep the glory for ourselves however long we can? God in scripture promises us to inhabit His kingdom and share in His glory. But He gets to say how that happens. He is God. We are not. We have repeatedly tried to create our own worlds for ourselves. It has never worked out real well.